His Bobby is a longhaired gal he hung out with for a while, and didn't they have a hell of a time. He's got no time for any hippie sentimentality. Jerry Lee Lewis's is a bit of a shock if all you know is Joplin's. There are a lot of memorable performances of this song. Kristofferson's diction could get a little bookish at times–"the coal mines of Kentucky," "she's looking for that home I hope she'll find"–and it doesn"t quite fit with things like "nothin' ain't worth nothin'" and "through everything I done." Joplin does a nice job of roughening it up a bit: "the KEN-tucky coal mines" (which makes a nice parallel with "the California sun"), "he's looking for that home and I hope he finds it." Quick summary: (mouth) harp for harmonica is an older expression but harpoon for harmonica seems to date from the 1969 song Me and Bobby McGee. September 13, 7:34 Taylor, thank you, for some reason the stored copy option is often missing in my browser but I thought someone else might provide a helpful link.Īnyhoo, I see that my memory condensed two separate things – his not wanting to talk about Jopin "It's like grave-robbin'" and a mild kvetch about her changing his was curious about that too… so I looked a little and found this: No comments on "harpoon"? I always assumed it was "pulled my harp on out of". For years I thought the line was "Freedom's just another word for nothing left to do", which I still think makes more logical sense.Ĭliff - paywall - as often, Google is your friend. I first heard Me and Bobby McGee from the Grateful Dead. Sometimes the immediacy of a first take works really well, even though it may have various minor imperfections. But Janis died and that was the only vocal track they had. It was not intended to be the final version that would be released. Janis Joplin's vocal was a rough track that would have been redone later on. Thanks for the memory! JJ is the best singer of this song, but a close second was the bass player of Chris Barber's Jazz Band – live. In the original lyrics, as sung by Roger Miller, Bobby McGee is a woman and the pronouns are "she" and "her." Like Joplin, Kristofferson is from Texas. He also was an outstanding student at Pomona and, later, at Merton College, Oxford, as a Rhodes Scholar. So he went back out ion tour, though he did start one song and stop saying he couldn’t remember more. Turns out it was tertiary (neurological) Lyme disease that responded to treatment. A couple more items about him: he had stopped performing because he couldn’t remember his songs. Louis (great venue) just maybe 3 years ago or so (Kris K I mean). "I'd trade all my tomorrows for a single yesterday, holding Bobbie's body next to mine" I placed it on my Facebook. His ability to dash down deep philosophical lines with such frugality of words was remarkable. Janice was able to rise in the bow of Kris's poetry. The chance combination of these two talents was a gift to all struggling young couples in that era. I think he was a very talented poet, but just couldn't sing a note I wanted to hear. Which is strange because it is the only Janice Joplin song I ever liked. "Bobby McGee" has always been one of my favorite songs. I see the interview is online, but behind a paywall I have no interest in crossing…. Specifically IIRC he was dissatisfied with her phrasing which didn't follow the rhythms he'd written very closely, especially around the line "windshield wipers slappin' time" Judging from the way he concludes this version, it almost sounds as though it were still in process of composition.įor some reason an old interview with Kristofferson got stuck in my mind….Īnyhoo, what I remembered was that he seemed a little critical of Joplin's interpretation, while probably not feeling comfortable openly criticizing an official Legend and a recording that presumably made a lot of money for him (it had been a billboard #1). " Kris Kristofferson 'Me & Bobby McGee' 1970 (Reelin' In The Years Archive)" Here's a very early version by Kris Kristofferson. Foster, he is listed as one of the writers of the song, but I never heard him perform it. September 12, 7:42 you or someone else provide a link to KK's original performance? I know that, together with F. Joplin's version is a pretty straight cover. ![]() Kris Kristofferson wrote the song,and the nonsense syllable verse was part of his original composition and performance. ![]() ![]() Filed by Victor Mair under Language and music, Language and psychology." Morphophonetic aesthetics" (4/8/11) - discusses lexical earworm infections.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Details
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |